Tag Archives: meteorites

Sometimes ad hominem is warranted

Posted on 1/15/2013 by Scott Aikin

Phil Plait’s got a serious take-down of the recent claim that there’s been a meteorite found that has diatom fossils in it (at Salon).  Plait’s case is along a few lines: (1) that the rock doesn’t look like it’s a … Continue reading →

Posted in Ad Hominem, Ad Hominem Abusive, Argument Analysis | Tagged , | 10 Comments